Biotic resistance affects growth and reproduction, but not survival of a high-impact woody invader in African savannas

Mariska te Beest*, Nokukhanya J. Mpandza, Han Olff

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

1 Citation (Scopus)
51 Downloads (Pure)


Question: Biotic resistance is defined as the reduction in invasion success caused by the native community through competition, herbivory and/or pathogens. Biotic resistance has mostly been studied during the initial stages of invasion. However, to what extent biotic resistance hampers survival, or persistence, of invaders in the longer term is often not known. We studied how native grassland communities affected growth, reproduction and survival during the adult life stage of the high-impact woody invader Chromolaena odorata under different water availability treatments. Location: Hluhluwe-iMfolozi Park, South Africa. Methods: We performed a 2-years full-factorial field experiment in a savanna grassland where we manipulated water availability and neighbouring vegetation; in one-third of the plots vegetation was cleared and planted with C. odorata monocultures, in one-third C. odorata shrubs were planted in grasslands, and one-third were unplanted grassland controls. Results: Growth and reproduction of adult C. odorata were greatly reduced due to competition with native grasses, but not survival of C. odorata. Shrub survival was high and did not differ in plots with and without grass. Water availability did not affect growth, reproduction and competitive ability of C. odorata, but higher water availability did increase the competitive ability of the grasses. Soil moisture levels were lower in grasslands planted with C. odorata compared to unplanted controls, independent of the water treatment, suggesting higher water use of C. odorata compared to native grasses. Conclusions: Savanna grasslands have a strong competitive effect on invasion by the exotic woody shrub C. odorata, reducing growth and reproduction, but not survival of the shrub. We found no evidence that biotic resistance was stronger under more unfavourable abiotic conditions, as C. odorata was equally impacted in all water treatments. The high survival rates of C. odorata suggest that competitive interactions are not likely to prevent invader persistence in the landscape. Invader persistence is important in determining longer-term invasion success as well as invader impact, and the concept of persistence should not be overlooked in studies on invasive species.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)532-540
Number of pages9
JournalJournal of Vegetation Science
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - May-2018


  • Chromolaena odorata
  • colonization
  • drought
  • exotic species
  • experiment
  • grassland
  • impact
  • invasion
  • moisture
  • persistence
  • water availability

Cite this