Implementing Reliability: The Interaction of Requirements, Tactics and Architecture Patterns

An important way that the reliability of a software system is enhanced is through the implementation of specific run-time measures called runtime tactics. Because reliability is a system-wide property, tactic implementations affect the software structure and behavior at the system, or architectural level. For a given architecture, different tactics may be a better or worse fit for the architecture, depending on the requirements and how the architecture patterns used must change to accommodate the tactic: different tactics may be a better or worse fit for the architecture. We found three important factors that influence the implementation of reliability tactics. One is the nature of the tactic, which indicates whether the tactic influences all components of the architecture or just a subset of them. The second is the interaction between architecture patterns and tactics: specific tactics and patterns are inherently compatible or incompatible. The third is the reliability requirements which influence which tactics to use and where they should be implemented. Together, these factors affect how, where, and the difficulty of implementing reliability tactics. This information can be used by architects and developers to help make decisions about which patterns and tactics to use, and can also assist these users in learning what modifications and additions to the patterns are needed.