The International Rule of Law and the Idea of Normative Authority

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)
117 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Domestic and international jurisprudence exist and develop as two 'pocket universes' in a sense that they belong to the same fabric of reality, but at the same time many concepts shift their meaning when moved from one pocket to another. This is of a paramount importance for the idea of the rule of law, which in domestic setting was forged in the flame of civil wars and struggles against the rulers. This history and such struggles are something international law has never known, and thus any direct transplantation of the domestic images of the rule of law to international realm are doomed to fail. This entails a need in deconstructing the rule of law. Its core meaning ('laws must be obeyed'), brings a normative claim relevant to any legal order. The idea of the (international) rule of law appears to be linked to the idea of authority of (international) law. There are differences of the structures of authority in domestic and international law as authority can be mediated or unmediated. Mediation of authority, typical for domestic law, presupposes the existence of officials that are functionally and institutionally differentiated from the subjects of law. Authority of international law is by and large unmediated because of its horizontal nature. Such reconstruction allows to reframe the central concern of the international rule of law enquiries. Instead of trying to fit it to the procrustean bed of domestic theories, international legal scholarship must focus on defining conditions under which international law's claim to authority is realisable.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)227-249
Number of pages23
JournalHague Journal of the Rule of Law
Volume12
Issue number2
Early online date16-Mar-2020
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug-2020

Keywords

  • International rule of law
  • Authority of international law
  • Normative authority
  • Legal normativity
  • DEFENSE

Cite this