The Potential Benefit of Radiotherapy with Protons in Head and Neck Cancer with Respect to Normal Tissue Sparing: A Systematic Review of Literature

Tara A. van de Water*, Hendrik P. Bijl, Cornelis Schilstra, Madelon Pijls-Johannesma, Johannes A. Langendijk

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalReview articlepeer-review

94 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Purpose. Clinical studies concerning head and neck cancer patients treated with protons reporting on radiation-induced side effects are scarce. Therefore, we reviewed the literature regarding the potential benefits of protons compared with the currently used photons in terms of lower doses to normal tissue and the potential for fewer subsequent radiation-induced side effects, with the main focus on in silico planning comparative (ISPC) studies.

Materials and Methods. A literature search was performed by two independent researchers on ISPC studies that included proton-based and photon-based irradiation techniques.

Results. Initially, 877 papers were retrieved and 14 relevant and eligible ISPC studies were identified and included in this review. Four studies included paranasal sinus cancer cases, three included nasopharyngeal cancer cases, and seven included oropharyngeal, hypopharyngeal, and/or laryngeal cancer cases. Seven studies compared the most sophisticated photon and proton techniques: intensity-modulated photon therapy versus intensity-modulated proton therapy (IMPT). Four studies compared different proton techniques. All studies showed that protons had a lower normal tissue dose, while keeping similar or better target coverage. Two studies found that these lower doses theoretically translated into a significantly lower incidence of salivary dysfunction.

Conclusion. The results of ISPC studies indicate that protons have the potential for a significantly lower normal tissue dose, while keeping similar or better target coverage. Scanned IMPT probably offers the most advantage and will allow for a substantially lower probability of radiation-induced side effects. The results of these ISPC studies should be confirmed in properly designed clinical trials. The Oncologist 2011;16:366-377

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)366-377
Number of pages12
JournalThe Oncologist
Volume16
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2011

Keywords

  • Proton therapy
  • Head and neck cancer
  • Radiotherapy
  • In silico treatment planning
  • Radiation-induced side effects
  • INTENSITY-MODULATED PHOTON
  • HELICAL TOMOTHERAPY
  • TREATMENT UNCERTAINTIES
  • RADIATION-THERAPY
  • PARTICLE THERAPY
  • PARANASAL SINUS
  • PAROTID-GLAND
  • CARCINOMA
  • VOLUME
  • TUMORS

Cite this